Comments on: Story Structure: A Lost Art? http://www.writehacked.com/writing/story-structure-a-lost-art/ Hack your writing. Self-publish your book. Tue, 26 Apr 2016 13:32:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=4.5 By: Nick Thacker http://www.writehacked.com/writing/story-structure-a-lost-art/#comment-8959 Sat, 31 Aug 2013 01:18:00 +0000 http://fb8.627.myftpupload.com/?p=4368#comment-8959 Same here — I’d love to find a book on the “other” structures that don’t get as much love!

]]>
By: rochellebarlow http://www.writehacked.com/writing/story-structure-a-lost-art/#comment-8958 Thu, 29 Aug 2013 03:49:00 +0000 http://fb8.627.myftpupload.com/?p=4368#comment-8958 Without structure our stories would be bags of skin. That’s icky. I love all the resources you’ve given on story structure. I just picked up Story Engineering (I know, I’m late to the game) the other day and am starting through it. I can’t wait for KM’s book to come out. I’m pretty special too, she must have missed me on the list… ha ha. I’m interested in reading more about the various act structures that Jessica brought up. I’ve mostly read about 3 and 4 acts. But, I am a newbie, so maybe that’s okay.

]]>
By: Nick Thacker http://www.writehacked.com/writing/story-structure-a-lost-art/#comment-8949 Wed, 28 Aug 2013 01:54:00 +0000 http://fb8.627.myftpupload.com/?p=4368#comment-8949 No problem — I’m still working through your book, too. It’s REALLY awesome, so I’m taking my time!

]]>
By: Nick Thacker http://www.writehacked.com/writing/story-structure-a-lost-art/#comment-8950 Wed, 28 Aug 2013 01:54:00 +0000 http://fb8.627.myftpupload.com/?p=4368#comment-8950 Good stuff here!

]]>
By: Jessica Burde http://www.writehacked.com/writing/story-structure-a-lost-art/#comment-8937 Sun, 25 Aug 2013 13:23:00 +0000 http://fb8.627.myftpupload.com/?p=4368#comment-8937 In general I agree with you, but you are kind of missing my point. I learned about 5-act structure long before 3-act structure. I wasn’t rambling off into the wilderness when I wrote my first stories using 5-act structure, I was following a different recipe.

Let me extend your analogy. I love to bake, and I’ve often had people ask me about baking bread. If someone came to me and said “I want to bake bread and I have these ingredients (story idea)” I wouldn’t say, “Well, you’re ingredients list includes eggs and milk, and those aren’t a part of white bread, so you can’t use them.” I would say, “Well here are two easy recipes, one is for white bread, but the eggs and milk don’t fit in this recipe, so if you want to use them, you’re better off following the challah recipe.”

I wouldn’t recommend a beginner making croissants (monomyth), until they’ve mastered some easier recipes. Hell I’ve been baking for nearly 10 years and my croissants still come out off more often than not! But letting a beginner know that there is a selection of easy recipes, and they can pick the one that they like best is not the same thing as encouraging them to get clever.

]]>
By: AlexBrantham http://www.writehacked.com/writing/story-structure-a-lost-art/#comment-8936 Sun, 25 Aug 2013 07:57:00 +0000 http://fb8.627.myftpupload.com/?p=4368#comment-8936 I’d agree that there is more than one way to structure a story, of course… and that any convention can easily become a strait-jacket. However, my guess is that most of the people interested in this blog post are likely to be closer to the “beginner” end of the spectrum than “master”.

Sure, when you’ve published a dozen best sellers you can do what the heck you like. But the single biggest mistake made by beginners (IMHO) is forgetting to have a structure to their story, so they just go rambling off into the wilderness in the hope that one or two readers might follow – and, when you’re beginning, following the recipe is a good way to start. You can always get clever later!

]]>
By: Nick Thacker http://www.writehacked.com/writing/story-structure-a-lost-art/#comment-8933 Thu, 22 Aug 2013 23:36:00 +0000 http://fb8.627.myftpupload.com/?p=4368#comment-8933 Hmm interesting comment, Guest. Thanks for the advice. While I disagree with your opinion, that’s your opinion.

And I guess I could publicly recognize every single person who’s ever helped me with anything in every post I write, but that would make for extremely long pos

I’ll continue to publicly recognize those people as I see fit. Thanks!

]]>
By: Guest http://www.writehacked.com/writing/story-structure-a-lost-art/#comment-8932 Thu, 22 Aug 2013 23:10:00 +0000 http://fb8.627.myftpupload.com/?p=4368#comment-8932 I read your post from beginning to end. you need to slow down and put more effort into your writting. you come off sounding like a salesman. going door to door, quickly repeating the same lines without thinking.

*Note*
you should publicly recognize the people who helped you. who knows, you might need their help again one day.

]]>
By: K.M. Weiland http://www.writehacked.com/writing/story-structure-a-lost-art/#comment-8930 Thu, 15 Aug 2013 22:10:00 +0000 http://fb8.627.myftpupload.com/?p=4368#comment-8930 Thanks for the shout out about Structuring Your Novel, Nick! Good post on a subject dear to my heart. 🙂 I haven’t seen The Lone Ranger yet, but I’m interested in giving it a watch just to see how far it strayed from proper structure. Badly structured scripts aren’t something you see too often in Hollywood. Bad stories and other problems, yes, but structure is something scriptwriters usually have a great handle on.

]]>